Hearth and Tap: Elevate Your Dining Experience with Exceptional Gastronomy in Montvale

Stopped by Hearth & Tap on 11/8/25 for lunch and had a great experience overall. The vibe was warm and lively -- good music, friendly staff, and quick service even though it was busy. The beef chili stood out -- rich, hearty, and packed with flavor. You can tell it's slow-cooked; the seasoning has depth without being too spicy, and the melted cheddar on top pulls it all together. Definitely worthy of that "award-winning" tag. The chicken quesadilla was another hit -- nicely grilled, full of tender chicken, peppers, and onions, and the sides (pico, sour cream, avocado) were fresh and balanced. The Hatco wrap was solid too -- crispy fried chicken with bacon and ranch, classic combo done right. Could've used a bit more sauce, but still tasty. Overall, Hearth & Tap delivers reliable comfort food with quality ingredients and good service. I'd definitely come back.

Great 1st experience for wife & I. A step back in time with this ol’ Irish Pub with jaw dropping surprises thru every door, around every turn, inside every room, up every staircase. Separate Cigar Bar straight out of the 1700’s and a private 2nd floor party room. Good food, decent prices, delicious coffee, great service and a truly edifying experience. Great anytime of day or date night. Hearth & Tap

Haven't been here since it was the old name, only because it's no longer close to me. Well, I'm just going to have to make the trip a bit more often. The outside setup was amazing! What a great time. Atmospher, food, and service were superb. I'm also a cigar smoker and this place is a great spot to smoke some cigars.

This review is about a week late, but well worth posting. Friends brought me over to Hearth and Tap for the first time on Friday 12/5/25. We do We'll get together every couple of months. Although I don't smoke cigars I agreed to come with them to this amazing venue. The decor is great, and you've got a non smoking room along with A very unique and friendly bar. But to be honest I was already at 4 stars just after meeting our waitress Erin. I don't throw superlatives around freely but this had to be one of the best waitresses ever. In addition to getting our orders right and all that mundane stuff, she was fun and exciting and kept us laughing all evening. We felt like we were regulars. I'm recovering from surgery with a sling and she was helpful with getting me up and down which just added to the positivity. I had the beef stroganoff which I would certainly recommend, but everything on the menu looks good. I'm definitely going to bring another group there sometime soon. And hope can get Erin to be our server again!

First time going here, very nice inside, kind of charming. And the food was very good, and the service was excellent. I couldn't ask for more for my waitress. Every one day, I wanted to make sure you had a good meal and you had a good time.

First time here for a holiday party. Erin was our bartender and she made some great cocktails. We all were delighted with our drinks and her quick service. She was not only courteous, but patient with our large group. The pizzas and coconut shrimp were my favorite apps. So yummy! Kept going back for more. We all had a great time and definitely will be back again.

We had a great lunch at Hearth & Tap, and everything from the food to the service made for an enjoyable experience. I had the ahi tuna burger, and it was excellent—the tuna was fresh, and the combination with arugula added a really nice touch. My family ordered the chicken pot pie and steak sliders, and both dishes were well-prepared and flavorful. The sangria and cranberry spritz were refreshing and reasonably priced, making for a nice addition to the meal. The service was friendly and prompt, and the restaurant itself was very clean, including the restrooms. There is a closed cigar room, so there’s a slight scent near the entrance, but once inside the main dining area, it’s not noticeable at all. Another plus is the ample parking, which makes visiting hassle-free. Overall, Hearth & Tap is a solid choice for a good meal in a comfortable setting—definitely worth a visit!

Desiree and Christian are wonderful! Came for a birthday and anniversary brunch and service was top notch. Highly recommend coming for the ambiance and quality service! Family friendly and delicious drinks! We will definitely be back!!!